Miss Penny Cakes
A beloved Brunswick West bakery whose rare 4.8 rating signals real craft and consistency.
Some links are affiliate links — if you book through them we may earn a small commission, at no extra cost to you. It never affects our Spot Score or what we recommend.
Why it's worth checking out
Tucked along Melville Road in Brunswick West, Miss Penny Cakes is the kind of neighbourhood bakery that locals quietly hope stays a secret. It has built a devoted following in Melbourne's inner north, and the numbers tell the story — a 4.8 rating across more than 160 reviews is rare air for a small suburban shopfront, and it points to consistency rather than hype.
The appeal here is craft over flash. This is a spot for picking up something special on the way home, lingering over coffee and a slice, or sorting out a celebration cake without trekking into the city. Brunswick West's leafy, residential streets make it an easy, unhurried stop, and the cakes do the talking.
If you're planning a visit around a particular cake, a custom order or a specific opening time, it's worth a quick message or call first, as small bakeries often sell out and keep their own hours. Check current details directly before you head over.
Reviewed by Iyan B.
Practical details
Opening hours
Open now- Monday
- 07:30 – 15:00
- TuesdayToday
- 07:30 – 15:00
- Wednesday
- 07:30 – 15:00
- Thursday
- 07:30 – 15:00
- Friday
- 07:30 – 15:00
- Saturday
- 08:30 – 14:00
- Sunday
- Closed
Spot Score
- Reputation
- 87
- Popularity
- 67
- Information quality
- 30
- Category fit
- 70
- Freshness
- 30
Our independent editorial score — not a user rating.
Nearby venues
Augie's Place - Dog Friendly Cafe & Licenced Bar
Cafes in Brunswick, Melbourne.
Lux Foundry
$$Fancy breakfasts and a global lunch menu in a hip onetime warehouse with a distressed interior.
Donatello's
Cafes in Brunswick, Melbourne.
Lobbs
$$Cafes in Brunswick, Melbourne.
More bakeries in Melbourne
Hung's Bakery
Highly rated bakery on Victoria Street in Richmond, Melbourne, with nearly 1,900 customer reviews.
Bakemono Bakers
Bakeries in Melbourne CBD, Melbourne.
A1 Bakery
$Lebanese bakery & Middle Eastern grocer selling bread, pita, pies, pizza & grocery items.
Levalicious
Bakeries in Fitzroy, Melbourne.